Pauline Martz

In spring of 1986, the ghastly murder of an elderly widow would lead to the shocking conviction of an innocent man, a breakdown of the justice system that would take nearly a decade to be corrected. Seventy-nine-year-old Pauline Martz lived alone in the small town of Aurora, Missouri. On April 13th, firefighters were called to … More Pauline Martz

The Maps Family Murder

It was the evening of Sunday, January 21st, 1962. The Maps family—thirty-nine-year-old artist Edward, his twenty-two-year-old wife Christine, and the couple’s four-month-old daughter Julie Louise—had been visiting with their neighbors since about eight-thirty p.m., eating an apple pie they had brought and having a pleasant chat. They left at a little past nine p.m. so … More The Maps Family Murder

Arthur Cope

Fifty-six-year-old van driver Arthur Cope was last seen by coworkers on the afternoon of Wednesday, October 7th, 1964. Presumably, after leaving work that day, he returned to his home, which was in a trailer at the Radcliffe-on-Trent Caravan Park on Wharf Lane in Nottingham, England. Two days later, police discovered Arthur’s body in his residence. … More Arthur Cope

Clifton Walker

Thirty-seven-year-old Clifton Walker, affectionately nicknamed “Man” by his family, was a veteran of the Korean War, though he had been honorably discharged from the Army after a leg injury. He and his wife Ruby had five children, and lived on their own land in Woodville, Mississippi. In 1964, Clifton was working as a laborer at … More Clifton Walker

Margaret Sheeler

Only a few days before 1963 came to a close, a pregnant woman in Canada would apparently wander out into the snow and meet her doom shortly thereafter, at the hands of an unknown assailant. Twenty-year-old Margaret Sheeler lived with her husband Philip in a townhouse in London, Ontario. She had gotten pregnant the previous … More Margaret Sheeler

Judith Reeder

February 2nd, 1962 was a Friday night, and pretty high school senior Judi (sometimes spelled Judy) Reeder was planning her usual night out with friends in Bend, Oregon. The seventeen-year-old got into her car in the early evening and headed toward town, but she evidently never made it to her destination. The following morning, her … More Judith Reeder

Michaela Hague

In Great Britain, on Bonfire Night of 2001, a woman would be savagely stabbed to death after setting off fireworks with her family. It was the evening of November 5th, and twenty-five-year-old Michaela Hague was celebrating Guy Fawkes Day at home in Pitsmoor, Sheffield, with her partner of six years, Mick Holmes, and their five-year-old … More Michaela Hague