Penny Doe

It was July 22nd, 1990, and some teenagers were exploring an area of Monroe Township, Pennsylvania, about three miles south of Interstate 80. They had just passed under a small railroad trestle when they noticed what they initially thought was a dead deer, lying in a shallow stream. But as they grew closer, they realized … More Penny Doe

Leonard Gomm

Leonard Gomm, a seventy-five-year-old husband, and a father of three grown daughters, had lived in the Oxford area of England for most of his life, and after retiring from the Cowley motor works some time before, had begun driving a taxi to earn some extra money and get him out of the house. By all … More Leonard Gomm

Susan Poupart

As the spring of 1990 began heading into summer, a Native American woman in the Midwestern United States would leave a party with two men and disappear shortly thereafter, only to turn up dead in late autumn of the same year. Twenty-nine-year-old mother of two Susan “Suzy” Poupart had been spending the evening of Saturday, … More Susan Poupart

Amy Mihaljevic

Only a few days before Halloween of 1989, a mysterious phone call arrived at the home of the Mihaljevic family in Bay Village, Ohio, just outside of Cleveland. Ten-year-old Amy Mihaljevic answered the phone, and presumably knew the man at the other end of the line. This unidentified individual told Amy to meet him at … More Amy Mihaljevic

Julie Doe

It was the morning of Sunday, September 25th, 1988, and a man was driving along Highway 474 in Lake County east of Orlando, searching for a perfect cypress tree to cut down and make furniture out of. Spotting a promising specimen, the man pulled over, but then began to notice a terrible smell wafting out … More Julie Doe

Nikki Benedict

On the evening of May 1st, 1967, in California, fourteen-year-old Nikki Benedict was walking home from a girlfriend’s house at around six p.m. As she took a short cut along a dirt road in the then-unincorporated town of Poway, near San Diego, she was attacked by a person or persons unknown. About a half-hour later, … More Nikki Benedict

Wharlest Jackson

Thirty-six-year-old Wharlest Jackson, Jr. was a veteran of the Korean War and a Florida native. He had moved to Natchez, Mississippi more than a decade earlier to marry his sweetheart Exerlena, who had been born there. The couple had five children. In the early part of 1967, Wharlest had been offered a promotion at the … More Wharlest Jackson

Gloria Fay Slump

In the early spring of 1967, twenty-four-year-old secretary Gloria Fay Slump was excited to introduce her parents to a nice new man she had met. She phoned them on March 3rd and said she would bring him over for a weekend visit. She never arrived. On Monday, March 6th, workers at the Burlington Railroad discovered … More Gloria Fay Slump

Judy Ann Corbin

Seventeen-year-old Judy Ann Corbin had always been something of a wild child, and during her younger years had spent some time in the juvenile justice system during her family’s stint in California, while her father was serving there in the Navy. After the Corbins had moved back to their native Iowa, Judy had struck out … More Judy Ann Corbin

Denise Sue Clinton

Denise Sue Clinton was an adorable nine-year-old with a reddish-blonde pixie cut, freckles, and a maturity far beyond her years. In early July of 1965, she had just come back from a two-week vacation in California with her parents and her six-year-old sister Diana. On the evening of July 7th, her parents dropped her off … More Denise Sue Clinton