In the summer of 1974, a gruesome find near a beach in the Northeastern United States would mark the beginning of one of Massachusetts’ most compelling mysteries. It was the afternoon of July 26th, and a thirteen-year-old girl was looking for her dog, which had run from a nearby cottage on the Cape Cod National … More The Lady of the Dunes

Twenty-eight-year-old Carolyn Montgomery lived in North Dallas, Texas with her son Dequin, who was six years old in 1971. She shared a flat in the Sherwood Forest Apartments complex with another female roommate, who also worked at the same upscale nightclub where Carolyn was employed as a cocktail waitress. After a long shift, Carolyn came … More Carolyn Montgomery

On the day before Valentine’s Day of 1983, a body was found alongside a West Virginia highway, and although law enforcement weren’t aware of it yet, the dead woman may have been the first discovered victim of a possible serial killer who seemed to target red-haired females. An elderly couple was traveling along Route 250 … More The Redhead Murders

St. Augustine, Florida was founded by the Spanish in 1565, and is considered the oldest continually occupied European settlement in the United States. Because of its age and colorful history involving bloody battles and pirate raids, the town is packed full of marvelous eerieness: the Huguenot cemetery, crumbling and atmospheric, like something out of a … More Athalia Ponsell Lindsley & Frances Bemis

It was March 27th, 1971, and off-duty special constable David Nathan was taking a stroll on an island in the River Trent in Staffordshire when he spotted something that appeared to be part of a bag of cement poking out of the soil. Curious, he retrieved a spade and began digging. Unfortunately, what Nathan found … More Pink Socks, aka Fred the Head