Thirty-two-year-old Nancy S. Smith was a dedicated professional working as the manager of Payor Contracting for the Greater Hudson Valley Health System at Horton Memorial Hospital in Middletown, New York. She owned her own home, was pursuing a Master’s degree in Public Administration through an accelerated program at Marist College, and was known for her strong work ethic and reliability.
Friends and classmates described her as responsible, determined, and no-nonsense, but also fun-loving. She enjoyed music, barbecues, birthday parties, and vacations like one to Key West. She was close to her family, particularly her parents, Lenore and Ed Smith, speaking with her mother the night before her death. Though safety-conscious and averse to confrontation, she had once taken a self-defense class where her discomfort with conflict was evident.
On the morning of December 5th, 2001, Nancy did not show up for work and had not called in sick, which was highly unusual behavior for her. Her office contacted her parents, who grew concerned after multiple unanswered calls. They went to her Provost Drive home around one-thirty p.m. and discovered her body in the living room, covered with blankets and pillows. She was still in her pajamas.
Autopsy findings revealed she had been hit in the head, strangled, and stabbed multiple times (reports vary from over a dozen wounds). A knife believed to be the murder weapon was left at the scene. There were signs of a violent struggle, but no evidence of forced entry or robbery; nothing appeared to be missing. Investigators believed the killer was likely someone she knew.
The New Windsor Police Department, New York State Police, and FBI have investigated the case for years. It has been revisited multiple times, with public appeals on anniversaries. Rewards have been offered to generate leads: the FBI has provided up to $15,000, while local authorities raised the total to as much as $50,000 in recent years for information leading to an arrest and conviction.
Flyers remain posted in the community, and detectives have maintained active files. Sheila Davalloo, convicted in other violent crimes in the region around that time, was interviewed in connection with the case but has never been charged in Nancy Smith’s murder, which remains unsolved as of 2026.
Crime Immemorial 