Nathan Tinglof

Nathan Adam Tinglof had spent much of his adult life exploring America, traveling across the country on foot and hopping freight trains before eventually settling in New Orleans, Louisiana. Known affectionately as “Neight Train,” the thirty-year-old Indiana native had transformed his adventurous spirit into a life in the Crescent City, where he operated his own small business. But in the early morning hours of September 23rd, 2016, that life came to a violent and mysterious end.

Born on June 16th, 1986, Nathan Tinglof grew up in Valparaiso, Indiana. From an early age, he developed an independent and adventurous outlook that would eventually take him far beyond his Midwestern hometown.

After finishing school, Nathan embarked on an unconventional journey across the United States. Rather than following a traditional path, he traveled extensively on foot and by hopping trains, embracing a nomadic lifestyle that allowed him to experience different places and communities firsthand. Nathan had visited nearly every state in the country by the time his travels brought him to New Orleans.

Eventually, he established himself in New Orleans and started a business called Gutters, Homes and Gardens. He also built a personal life in the city, where he was in a relationship with Hayley Knafel.

In the early morning darkness of Friday, September 23rd, 2016, residents of New Orleans’ St. Roch neighborhood were disturbed by gunfire.

At approximately three fifteen a.m., officers with the New Orleans Police Department responded to reports of shots fired near the intersection of North Villere and Arts streets. When they arrived in the 2400 block of North Villere Street, they discovered a man lying facedown in the roadway. Nearby was a white Dodge Ram flatbed pickup truck.

The victim had suffered a gunshot wound to his chest. Emergency responders were unable to save him, and he was pronounced dead at the scene. On September 26th, Orleans Parish Coroner Jeffrey Rouse publicly identified the victim as Nathan Tinglof.

Investigators were left with several fundamental questions. Why had Nathan been on that particular street at such an early hour? Had he been deliberately targeted, or had he encountered someone unexpectedly? What had happened in the moments before the gunshot?

The circumstances were especially puzzling because of what police found at the scene. According to friends who later spoke to WGNO, the white pickup belonged to Nathan and its engine was still running when officers arrived. His wallet was also recovered at the scene, suggesting that an ordinary robbery might not have been the motive.

Friends were perplexed by the location itself. At the time, North Villere Street was riddled with potholes, making it an unusual route for someone driving through the neighborhood. They could not explain why Nathan would have been traveling along that stretch of road in the middle of the night.

Within days of the killing, investigators identified what appeared to be one of their most promising leads: a vehicle captured on surveillance footage. On October 3rd, 2016, the New Orleans Police Department released a grainy security-camera image showing a dark-colored, four-door sedan. Detectives believed the vehicle had been used by the person responsible for Nathan Tinglof’s murder.

Police hoped that someone might recognize the car or provide information about its driver. However, the surveillance image did not immediately produce a publicly announced breakthrough. The vehicle’s driver was not publicly identified, and no arrest was reported in the contemporary coverage.

As the years passed, Nathan Tinglof’s murder received renewed attention through WGNO’s Wheel of Justice, a recurring television feature that revisits unsolved crimes in the New Orleans area. In September 2024, eight years after the shooting, the station reported that police still had not established a motive or identified the person responsible. The dark sedan remained a central element of the public appeal for information.

Two years later, on September 24th, 2026, WGNO revisited the case again, marking the tenth anniversary of Nathan’s death.

And as of this writing more than a decade later, there has been no publicly reported resolution.


Leave a Reply