Nora Fuller

Fifteen-year-old Eleanor “Nora” Fuller had been born in China but later lived in San Francisco with her mother and three siblings. The previous year had been a rough one for the Fullers, as Nora‘s parents had recently divorced. Money was tight, and Nora was obliged to quit school in 1902 and begin looking for work. … More Nora Fuller

Athalia Ponsell Lindsley & Frances Bemis

St. Augustine, Florida was founded by the Spanish in 1565, and is considered the oldest continually occupied European settlement in the United States. Because of its age and colorful history involving bloody battles and pirate raids, the town is packed full of marvelous eerieness: the Huguenot cemetery, crumbling and atmospheric, like something out of a … More Athalia Ponsell Lindsley & Frances Bemis

Judy Smith

In 1997, in the northeastern United States, a truly bizarre murder mystery would begin to unfold whose every detail seems to suggest ever more improbable scenarios and whose outcome appears just as muddled today as it did when it first occurred. Fifty-year-old Judy Smith was a successful home-care nurse who lived in a wealthy suburb … More Judy Smith

Peggy Hettrick

It was around nine p.m. on the evening of Tuesday, February 10th, 1987 when thirty-seven-year-old Peggy Hettrick left her job at a clothing store called the Fashion Bar at the Foothills Mall in Fort Collins, Colorado, and began walking back to her nearby apartment. Her regular roommate, Barb Kohler, was out of town, but another … More Peggy Hettrick

Rachael Runyan

In the last summer of 1982, a little girl would be abducted only a few feet from her home and be found dead weeks later. Her murder would become instrumental in the establishment of a more codified law enforcement response to missing children cases, and serve as the basis for the 1983 passage of the … More Rachael Runyan

Ken Rex McElroy

In the Midwestern United States, in the summer of 1981, an extraordinary case would make headlines around the nation, a crime that would explore the uncomfortably gray area between the arguable breakdown of the rule of law and the conspiratorial actions of an alleged group of fed-up vigilantes. Residents of the tiny town of Skidmore, … More Ken Rex McElroy

Stephanie Hart-Grizzell & Nick Kunselman: The Subway Murders

In the winter of 2000, in a Colorado suburb still reeling from a notorious mass murder, a shocking double homicide in a sandwich shop would devastate the community anew. It was the eve of Valentine’s Day, February 13th, and sixteen-year-old high school sophomore Stephanie Hart-Grizzell had spent the Sunday evening doing homework before saying good … More Stephanie Hart-Grizzell & Nick Kunselman: The Subway Murders